A Metropolitan Death Spiral

Can New York recover from its destruction by deBlasio and BLM?

Back in 2011, we explained why cities matter and how to kill them.  We never imagined that the death we predicted for our big cities would arrive so soon, but here we are.

Great American cities have recovered from major disasters - the San Francisco earthquake of 1906, the Watts riots of 1965, and the New York financial collapse in the early 1970s come to mind - but we believe that the one-two punch of the lockdown due to the Covid-19 virus combined with government officials permitting the so many destructive riots mean that our major cities may have entered into a final death spiral.

Cities offer major advantages.  Gathering large numbers of people together in the same place brings more buyers and sellers close enough together to do more business together more efficiently.

Large numbers of people can share ideas, experiments, and figure out what works and what doesn't work.  The concentration of lawyers, financiers, traders, and other specialists makes it easier to get new businesses going, which contributes to overall wealth.

There is a moral cost to cities, in that personal relationships are weaker when there are so many nearby people whom we don't know.  This makes it easier for people to feel justified in breaking laws.

Bad actors can see this anonymity as an advantage, of course - as Bertie Wooster put it, "What's the point of a big city having temptations if a young man can't yield to them?" - but looser morals lead to increased crime rates.  That makes police forces essential for maintaining the general order which is so essential to business and peaceful lives for commoners who can't afford theri own private security forces.

We've explained why our large cities have been under serious survival pressure for decades.  Vote-buying politicians give raises and promise unaffordable pensions to city employees and increase welfare spending which forces taxes up.  This drives working people out of the city.  This Harvard-defined "Curley effect" decreases tax revenue even while spending goes up because there is no end to demands for more benefits by various voting blocks.

Building codes and zoning regulations limit the housing supply which drives up rents.  Low-income people get subsidized apartments, rich people can afford lavish guarded penthouses, and the middle class is driven out.

The higher taxes get, the more people leave.  Mayor Michael Bloomberg observed that "One percent of the households that file in this city pay something like 50% of the taxes.  In the city, that's something like 40,000 people."  Back in 2009, the New York Post told us that one out of seven New York city taxpayers left between 2000 and 2008.

We see similar exodus from high-cost California cities like San Fransisco and Los Angeles.  Unfortunately, refugees from Democrat misrule don't seem to know why they had to leave and keep voting Democrat in their new domiciles, driving them into the ground too.

How Did Cities Recover?

San Fransisco recovered rapidly from the 1906 earthquake because the economic potential of California was just beginning to be realized and the entire state was booming.  The New York financial collapse was caused by the familiar process of over-spending, which was cured by appointing an oversight board which forced the city to live within its means - there were actual pay cuts and reductions in headcount!

The next crisis came in an increased crime rate which peaked during Mayor Dinkins' term of 1990-1993.  The atmosphere of fear and menace in the subways was easily felt even by unsophisticated people from out of town.

Rudy Giuliani, who had served as a United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, served as mayor from 1994 to 2001.  He appointed William Bratton as police commissioner, who applied the "broken windows" theory of crime.

He believed that minor disorders create a permissive atmosphere which leads to serious crimes which threaten overall city safety.  He directed his police officers to enforce minor "quality-of-life" laws such as outlawing public drinking, littering, and jay-walking to encourage better behavior.  Commissioner Bratton also used a computer system to track neighborhoods where crimes occurred so that he could position police officers in high-crime areas.  These policies were continued and extended under Mayor Michael Bloomberg.

"Broken windows" policies were criticized as "racist" because more blacks were accused than would be justified by their share of the population.  Such policies were more or less abandoned under Mayor DeBlasio and crime rates were steadily climbing before the virus hit the city.  The NYPD disbanded its 600-strong plainclothes squad whose job was to keep illegal guns off the streets and recently stopped using crime statistics to send extra police to high-crime areas because it flooded minority neighborhoods with extra cops even though blak New York residents want more police protection, not less.

The Lockdown Knock Out

When the coronavirus hit, the mayor of New York was famously late in taking action.  Normally, his lazy neglect might have been beneficial by allowing business and commerce to continue, but the close-quarters condition of our greatest city coupled with its notoriously filthy subway are the most effective Petri dish for spreading diseases of all time.  Eventually, the numbers of sick and dying climbed to the point where drastic action became a not unreasonable policy, and, driven by the doomsday media, he ordered cessation of normal metropolitan life.

Locking down the city had several undesirable effects.  Small businesses, which had already been suffering from increased taxes and regulation under the mayor's misguided policies, were forced to shut down entirely.  The economic stimulus was supposed to help them meet payroll, but the application process was too complex for many and wouldn't have helped pay outrageous city rents.  Most of these independent small city service businesses won't be opening back up again even if the mayor allows it.

At the same time, many businesses which rented space in downtown office hives found that their employees could work nearly as effectively from home.  Although it's clear that efficiency suffers somewhat from people not being able to meet face-to-face, the loss of productivity seems to be turning out to be less than the savings in rent, to say nothing of the quality-of-life increases from not having to commute and being able to live somewhere - anywhere! - cheaper than Manhattan.

As workers are permitted back into offices, social distancing rules mean that offices hold 1/3 to 1/2 as many people as before.  Although prestigious buildings can command higher rents than would be considered normal, the value of an office building is determined by the value of the economic activity generated by tenants' employees who work in it.  If a building can accommodate only 1/3 as many employees, the economic value of the building is cut by 2/3.  This will eventually be reflected in the rent.  In turn, reduced rental income reduces the value of the building, which gives the owner a decent shot at asking for a property tax reduction.

History shows that when such economically-forced tax reductions aren't granted, owners skimp on maintenance and defer paying taxes as long as they can collect any rent at all, then simply abandon their properties when the roof falls in.  Over 40% of the South Bronx was burned or abandoned between 1970 and 1980.  44 census tracts lost more than 50% and seven more than 97% of their buildings to arson or abandonment.  Humorists pointed out that losing World War II to the Americans was healthier for a city than longstanding Democrat governance.

Locked-down commuters are finding that they don't have to come into the city to get their work done.  Due to media "panic porn," people are increasingly afraid of gathering in large groups needed to support theatres, concert halls, and sports facilities.  City residents are decamping to suburbs or to other states which reduces the traffic needed to support restaurants and retail.

Savvy New Yorkers know that the lockdown stopped sales tax income and dented income tax revenue.  They know that blue state governments always increase taxes instead of cutting spending, which gives them another reason besides the virus to leave.  Apartment rents are declining in New York and San Fransisco to a degree which was not seen during earlier economic slowdowns.  "Pandemic pricing" has arrived.

The lockdown makes investors less likely to start new businesses.  A Hillsdale lecture "The Economic Ramifications of Economic Shutdown" pointed out that this unprecedented business shutdown added immeasurably to the perceived risks of starting a business - you now must consider the possibility of a months-long forced delay at your expense.

Niche restaurants are one of the major benefactors of the diverse population of a large city, but most restaurants fail in their first year.  If a dedicated entrepreneur pours a lifetime of time, talent, and treasure into growing a business which can be swept away in a few weeks by an arbitrary government decree, sane entrepreneurs will be more reluctant to start businesses in large cities than they had been.

Then, the Black Lives Matter protests inspired by the death of George Floyd came just as cities were beginning to let restaurants open up.  Many owners saw their lifetime efforts destroyed by rampaging mobs as police, under direction of municipal authorities, allowed arsonists and looters free reign.  Ignoring rioters has emboldened other criminals, and violent gun-based municipal crime is climbing again in New York, Chicago, and Minneapolis.

In addition to calculating the risks of economic ruin brought about by a shutdown due to the next viral plague out of China, entrepreneurs have to think about the risks of being a victim of increasing city-based crime and of losing police protection as protests spin out of control during the next riot.

Cities Lose their Monopoly

It used to be said that anything you couldn't buy in New York, the city that never sleeps, couldn't be bought anywhere.  The lockdown showed that people could easily cope with the loss of access to the incredible variety of city stores by ordering from Amazon - there were moments when Amazon sold $10,000 worth of goods per second.

Here are the obstacles to New York coming back from the dead once again:

  1. The lockdown shows that governments can put a longstanding enterprise out of business on what turned out to be misguided whim in most of the nation.  The death toll has turned out to be no worse than a somewhat bad flu season, and we never shut down for the flu.  No politicians have paid any price for this mistake; most have simply increased their power.
  2. Blue state governments have shown themselves unwilling to defend stores against looters - "Property can be replaced; human lives cannot." Entrepreneurs will think yet again before starting new businesses.  Without places to work, people who don't qualify for subsidized housing can't afford to live in blue cities.
  3. Predictions based on "science" can't be trusted because they've become totally political.  The pandemic models were grossly inaccurate, and both The Lancet and the New England Journal of Medicine had to retract sloppily-written articles about the virus.  These once-revered publications and the frauds who wrote for them appear to have paid no price for their errors.
  4. The pro-lockdown forces showed utter hypocrisy in saying that semi-masked, block-long crowds protesting racism were OK while much smaller gatherings for churches, funerals, and Trump rallies were not OK.
  5. Government advice whether individuals who are not ill should wear masks or not has changed rapidly and inexplicably.  This further reduces overall confidence in all levels of government, including governments of our most violent cities, most of which have been run by Democrats for decades.
  6. People found that a lot of white-collar work that had been done in office skyscrapers could be done from their bedrooms via the Internet and video conferencing applications which weren't available during New York's earlier financial crisis.  There are more alternatives to the former city monopoly on high-density collaboration than in the past and people were forced to explore them.  They've been proven to work tolerably well, and will only get better as understanding grows.

Cities offer many advantages, but when the cost of living in a city exceeds the benefits, people will leave.  When the white middle class flees, black flight is not far behind.

Will Offensicht is a staff writer for Scragged.com and an internationally published author by a different name.  Read other Scragged.com articles by Will Offensicht or other articles on Economics.
Reader Comments

Democrats prospered from mismanagement for decades, confident that the dog would never catch that truck. Looks now that he just might, and he won't be the only one surprised when he does; we may all pay a terrible price.

June 29, 2020 8:29 PM

@fred johnston I believe that they're hoping that a Democrat will get the White House and they will be voted massive bailouts at the expense of better-managed states.

July 1, 2020 3:02 PM

The only reason cities exist is as a place to do business. Some start as military or other government stations, but in all cases they only continue and grow if there is profitable business to be done.

The most extreme examples are the ghost towns out west; they were boom towns until the mine shut down, then the town shut down too. But the same pattern exists in all cases, albeit usually a lot slower and less extreme.

Anything that strikes at the ease of doing business in a city strikes at the only reason it exists, so the key questions about any change should be "what does this do to the easy of business?" and "is that OK?".

Politicians never seem to understand that, even the ones who want to "help" businesses. Part of the problem is that it takes a big city a long time to die; Detroit isn't dead yet, but it has been sick for decades (others too). Since it takes a long time, cause and effect can be lost on politicians and the People. But not seeing the real problems, just the general result, is a recipe for doing the wrong thing, and that is what happens far too often.

An historical example: the US textile industry had been in New England for a long time; it was practically invented there. Then costs rose relative to elsewhere, so business there got harder, and it started to move south. After a while it was all gone. But costs in the South stated to become non-competitive with other areas, so it started to move there and leave the South, and soon it was all gone from there too. The politicians were surprised, because they forgot why business moved in, and did not understand that it would move out for the same reason. They thought the businesses just "were", forgetting their own history.

Contrast this with what the Germans did: in the late 90's Germany was "the sick man of Europe", but they faced their problems in 2000, and came up with a plan that addressed the need to be economically competitive. They analyzed what the real issues were, understood what was necessary to keep business and grow it, and did what was necessary. Germany has done better than the rest of Europe since.

July 4, 2020 7:55 PM

The photos on


show that it is better for an enemy city like Hiroshima to lose a nuclear war with America than to be a domestic city like Detroit which is ruled by Democrats.

July 5, 2020 7:11 PM

Others are catching on


Although some officers are taking early retirement, the police budget cuts haven't really started to bite yet. Just asking the cops to back off and let rioters riot has enboldened the bad guys. Instead of being afraid to carry illegal guns, they're carrying them around more.

Shootings have more than doubled compared with the same week last year.

Good opening for a "law and order" president?

July 6, 2020 9:28 AM

City Lab disagrees with you.


cites many cities such as Tokyo that recovered from total destruction after wars. It has lots of pictures of some pretty impressive damage contrasting with what the places look like now.

To be fair to you, we do not yet know just how badly the internet will damage the longstanding city monopoly on large groups of people being able to interact.

July 10, 2020 7:43 AM

A big part of the Dem's urban management model is out sourcing government to the unions. This results in votes and contributions. The unions manage the key services of education, law enforcement, and welfare. Unions, being monopolies, focus on the needs of dues paying members not the citizens. So we get an education system that doesn't educate and full of teachers biding time until a well paid retirement. A police force that doesn't discipline/cull its cops but keeps around the incompetent, or worse, ones. And a welfare system driven by a high case load. The more cases, the more employees and more dues. Best way to jack up case load is keep fathers away from families so they are dependent on the city for care.
The weak link in this are the chumps who actually pay, not take, taxes. As this essay points out, tax payers want some sort of return on their investment.... educated students, effective law enforcement, and a social safety net that doesn't discourage work. Those folks now have options, Hopefully it will break the Dem/union strangle hold on cities.

July 10, 2020 9:17 AM

https://nypost.com/2020/07/12/its-not-just-police-public-servants-are-now-under-assault/ agrees with you. It is not ony cops who are being dissed - all authorities are being attacked.

July 13, 2020 11:40 AM

One more point relates to big city black vs white interaction. Whites are developing a healthy respect for black violence. A few "polar bear" videos gets attention. Whites are going to avoid blacks at all costs--reasonably so may I suggest. Trump Jr described the black avoidance in his 'bowl of Skittles' theory. 2000 Skittles in a bowl, and 2 of them will kill you. How many you want? Avoiding blacks is the new norm.
I believe the Democrats jumped the gun by utilizing George Floyd's overdose as the Antifa/BLM fiasco ttigger. Peaked too soon. Add to that Chauven's prosecution will be complicated by Floyd's tox report. Floyd would have died no matter.

July 30, 2020 2:30 AM

The word is spreading.


The true believers who remain are enthusiastic leftists who justify — or welcome — the dissolution of law and order.

New York City must be one of the few places on earth where chaos nostalgia is widespread. Many were the laments, in the Giuliani-Bloomberg era, that the city was “too sanitized,” “too gentrified,” “too boring,” “anodyne,” “suburban.” Often you’d hear people saying, or declaiming, that their ideal vision of the city was the 1970s–1980s one — oh, for the New York of CBGB, of Lou Reed, of the Tompkins Square Park riots. Occasionally people would sneeringly express revulsion that the sidewalks were teeming with strollers. What have we done, we’ve made this place safe enough for babies! And yet the population, which was smaller in 1990 than it was in 1940, boomed. More than a million more New Yorkers squeezed in between 1990 and 2010. It was as if a city the size of Austin grew atop the existing city.

On a return visit this weekend to the Upper West Side neighborhood where I’ve lived for more than a quarter of a century, the fear in the air was palpable. The population seemed to be reduced by about half. New Yorkers steer around each other on the sidewalks, some of them walking in the street to avoid passing near a stranger. A lady declined to ride the elevator with me and my children. People are especially terrified of the subway, whose ridership is down 80 percent from normal levels. Friday night, at a time when there would ordinarily be 50 or more people riding on any given car of the 1 train, there were about seven. Downtown was morose, grim, broken. Graffiti (the anarchists’ symbol, “ACAB” for “All Cops Are Bastards”) was much in evidence.

It goes on into much depressing detail....

August 10, 2020 1:37 PM
Add Your Comment...
4000 characters remaining
Loading question...